plum
Behaviour guide

A strong Changing and Improving example, step by step

One time you spotted a way of working that wasn't working, suggested a better one, helped people switch to it, and showed it made things better.

Changing and Improving is not about big transformation projects. At entry grades the panel wants one time you looked at how something was done, saw a better way, and made it happen with the people around you.

A common mistake is to describe a change that happened to the person, not a change the person made. Below: what the behaviour asks for at your grade, the answer most people write next to the one that scores, the full answer, and how to reuse it.

What the behaviour is asking for

Changing and Improving is one of the behaviours in Success Profiles, the framework that sets what each job tests. GOV.UK sums it up as: “Seek out opportunities to create effective change and suggest innovative ideas for improvement. Review ways of working, including seeking and providing feedback.”

At Administrative Assistant (AA) and Administrative Officer (AO) level, GOV.UK's lines include “review ways of working and suggest improvements, including how to make full use of new digital technologies” and “learn new procedures and help colleagues to do the same”.

At Executive Officer (EO) level, the lines include “regularly review own and team's work and take the initiative to suggest ideas to make improvements”, “help others to understand changes and the reasons they are being put in place” and “consider accessibility needs of the diverse range of end users”.

So the strongest answers show four things: what wasn't working and how you knew, the change you suggested, how you brought people with you, and the proof it worked. GOV.UK also says you don't need to show every line to do well.

At Higher Executive Officer (HEO) and Senior Executive Officer (SEO) level the bar rises: “work with others to identify areas for improvement and simplify processes to use fewer resources” and “encourage ideas for change from a wide range of sources”.

The shape below still works at those grades; the change is just bigger and involves more people.

Your example doesn't have to come from an office job. Success Profiles says it might be at work or somewhere else, such as work experience, volunteering or a hobby. The example below is made up and comes from a school office.

The advert or candidate pack says how each behaviour is scored and what the pass mark is, so check it before you write. The lines below show what a strong answer looks like.

Each part: what most people write, and what scores

Your answer has five parts: Situation, Task, Action, Result and Reflection (STARR). For each one, here is the line most people write, the line that scores, and why. Spend most of your words on the action.

Situation: show what wasn't working

Most people write

“I am always looking for ways to improve things and I embrace change.”

Write instead

“I work in a secondary school office. Permission slips for trips went home on paper, and about a third came back late or not at all, so staff spent days chasing them before every trip.”

Why it scoresThe first is a claim about yourself. The second names a real problem, with a sign of how big it was, which is where every change answer should start.

Task: say what was yours to fix

Most people write

“My manager asked the team to look at the process.”

Write instead

“Collecting slips was part of my job. Nobody had asked me to change it, but I thought a form parents could fill in online would save time, so I decided to look into it.”

Why it scoresThe first makes it someone else's idea. The second shows you took the initiative, which is the first EO line in plain words.

Action: where the marks are

Most people write

“I came up with a new digital system and everyone was happy to use it.”

Write instead

“I checked what tools the school already had, and its email system included a free online form tool. I asked two teachers and a parent rep what they needed, built a form, and tried it on one Year 8 trip first. I kept a paper copy for families without internet. Then I wrote a one-page guide and sat with each trip lead for 10 minutes to show them how to use it.”

Why it scores“New system” can't be scored. The second shows you reviewed the way of working, used digital tools you already had, asked for feedback, thought about families who can't go online, and helped colleagues learn it: the AO and EO lines, in plain words.

Result: prove it worked

Most people write

“It was a big success and saved a lot of time.”

Write instead

“On the trial trip, 95% of slips were back by the deadline, up from about 65%. The head of year asked me to use the form for every trip that term, and chasing time dropped from about 2 days per trip to half a day.”

Why it scoresThe first can't be checked. The second compares before and after with numbers, and shows the change was kept, which is what makes it an improvement and not just an idea.

Reflection: one thing you'd change

Most people write

“I learned that change is a good thing.”

Write instead

“Next time I'd test the form with 2 or 3 parents before the trial. They found two confusing questions that I could have fixed before any family saw it.”

Why it scoresThe first is true of everyone. The second says what you'd do differently and why, which shows you learnt something real.

The full answer

STARR example · Changing and Improving

Moving trip permission slips online

Situation + Task 20%Action 60%Result 20%
S

I work in a secondary school office. Permission slips for trips went home on paper, and about a third came back late or not at all, so staff spent days chasing them before every trip.

T

Collecting slips was part of my job. Nobody had asked me to change it, but I thought a form parents could fill in online would save time, so I decided to look into it.

A

I checked what tools the school already had, and its email system included a free online form tool. I asked two teachers and a parent rep what the form needed to collect, including medical notes and emergency contacts, and built a first version. I suggested trying it on one Year 8 trip before changing anything else, and my manager agreed. I kept a paper copy for families without internet or who preferred paper, and made sure the form worked on a phone. After the trial, I fixed two questions parents had found confusing. Then I wrote a one-page guide and sat with each trip lead for 10 minutes to show them how to set up their own form and check replies, and explained it would save them chasing slips.

R

On the trial trip, 95% of slips were back by the deadline, up from about 65%. The head of year asked me to use the form for every trip that term, and chasing time dropped from about 2 days per trip to half a day.

R

Reflection: Next time I'd test the form with 2 or 3 parents before the trial. They found two confusing questions that I could have fixed before any family saw it.

Tips for writing yours

  1. Start with the problem

    Open with what wasn't working and a sign of how big it was. Without a clear problem, the change has nothing to improve.

  2. Make it your idea

    Say what you noticed and suggested. A change your manager announced and you went along with shows adapting, not improving.

  3. Keep it your size

    At AO and EO a small process fix is the right scale: a form, a checklist, a rota, a shared folder. You don't need a restructure.

  4. Test before you roll out

    A small trial shows you managed the risk. It also gives you a before and after number for the result.

  5. Bring people with you

    Say how you asked for feedback and helped colleagues learn the new way. Both are named in the AO and EO lines.

  6. Think about who it could leave out

    One line on people the change might not suit, and what you did for them, covers the EO line on accessibility.

Use the same example for another question

Write your example as blocks first: one sentence each for the problem, your idea, who you asked, the trial, how you helped people switch, and the result. For a different question, keep the blocks and change which ones go in the middle.

In one application, try to use a different example for each behaviour. Blocks help most at interview, when a follow-up comes and you already know which part of your story answers it.

Delivering at Pace: tell me about a time you got something done to a deadline.

Say

Lead with the deadline and what was at risk, then how you planned the work and kept it moving.

Like this

Slips for a Year 8 trip had to be in 2 weeks before it left, and a third usually came back late. I set up an online form, kept a paper option, and checked replies daily. 95% were in by the deadline.

What to do next

Before you write yours

7 to do

Tonight, think of one time you thought “there must be a better way to do this” and then did something about it: at work, at uni, or somewhere you volunteer. Write it as blocks, then build the answer above around it.

For the same layout on other behaviours, see the Working Together, Delivering at Pace, Making Effective Decisions and Seeing the Big Picture guides.

Plum matches you to live Civil Service jobs, shows which behaviours each one tests, and helps you write and practise your examples. You apply on Civil Service Jobs itself.

Common questions

What is Changing and Improving in the Civil Service?

It is one of the Civil Service behaviours in Success Profiles. GOV.UK describes it as seeking out opportunities to create effective change, suggesting ideas for improvement, and reviewing ways of working, including seeking and giving feedback.

What is a good example of Changing and Improving?

One time you noticed a way of working that wasted time or let people down, suggested a better way, tested it, helped colleagues switch, and can show the before and after. Moving a paper process online works well.

I'm applying for an AO job. Does my change need to be big?

No. At AA and AO level GOV.UK asks you to review ways of working and suggest improvements, learn new procedures and help colleagues do the same. A small fix to how your team works is the right scale.

Can I use a change my manager brought in?

Only if you did something real within it, such as spotting a problem with it, suggesting a fix, or helping others learn it. Just going along with a change rarely scores well, because the behaviour is about what you did.

Can my example come from outside work?

Yes. Success Profiles says examples can come from work experience, volunteering or a hobby. Improving how a club, society or community group runs counts, as long as the idea and the action were yours.

What score do I need to pass a behaviour?

The advert or candidate pack sets how behaviours are scored and the pass mark. Check it, and check whether the advert names a lead behaviour.

Write your examples with Plum

See which behaviours each live job tests, and get help turning your experience into answers.

Open Plum