A strong Communicating and Influencing example, step by step
“I'm a good communicator” scores nothing. The panel scores what you did to get a message across, and what changed because of it. Show who you were talking to, why it was hard, how you chose to say it, and how you listened.
Below: the answer most people write next to the one that scores, the full answer, and how to reuse it for another question.
What the behaviour is asking for
Communicating and Influencing is one of the nine behaviours in Success Profiles, the framework that sets what each job tests. GOV.UK sums it up as: “Communicate purpose and direction with clarity, integrity and enthusiasm. Respect the needs, responses and opinions of others.”
At Administrative Officer (AO) level, one GOV.UK line is “use an appropriate method of communication for each person - for example an email, phone call, face-to-face - taking into consideration their individual needs”. Another is “listen and ask questions to ensure your understanding”.
At Executive Officer (EO) level, the lines include “communicate clearly and concisely both orally and in writing”, “respond constructively and objectively to comments and questions” and “handle challenging conversations with confidence and sensitivity”.
So the strongest answers show four things: a clear message, the right way to reach each person, real listening, and a result. Influencing just means people did or thought something different because of what you said.
ask for Communicating and Influencing
Plum data: 2,267 Civil Service operations and admin advertsYour example doesn't have to come from an office job. Success Profiles says it might be at work or somewhere else, such as work experience, volunteering or a hobby. The example below is made up and comes from a part-time job at a leisure centre.
At work, the same shape fits explaining a new rule to customers, getting a team to use a new form, or telling someone a decision they won't like.
Behaviours are usually scored out of 7. The advert or candidate pack sets the pass mark, and 4 is common. The lines below show what a high score looks like.
Each part: what most people write, and what scores
Your answer has five parts: Situation, Task, Action, Result and Reflection (STARR). For each one, here is the line most people write, the line that scores, and why. Spend most of your words on the action: around 150 words in a 250-word answer.
Situation: show why the message was hard
“I communicate with lots of people every day in my role, both customers and colleagues.”
“I work on reception at a leisure centre. We moved class bookings to an app with two weeks' notice, and many of our regulars had always booked by phone.”
Why it scoresThe first describes your job, not a moment. The second names the audience and why the message would be hard for them to hear.
Task: say what you had to get across
“I had to tell people about the change.”
“My manager asked me to make sure regular members knew how to book before phone bookings stopped, so nobody lost their place in a class.”
Why it scoresThe second says what success looked like: people able to book, not just told. That gives the result something to be measured against.
Action: where the marks are
“I explained the change clearly to everyone and answered their questions.”
“I wrote a one-page guide in plain words with screenshots, and phoned the ones who never used email. Several said they'd stop coming, so I asked what worried them. I took that to my manager and suggested keeping one phone line for 4 weeks.”
Why it scores“Clearly” can't be scored. The second shows a method chosen for each person, plain language, listening, and a suggestion your manager agreed to: the GOV.UK lines, in plain words.
Result: what changed because of you
“Everyone understood and it went well.”
“By the end of the 4 weeks, 31 of the 38 regulars were booking in the app, and the other 7 book at the front desk, which I set up with my manager.”
Why it scoresThe first can't be checked. The second gives a number and shows that what you said changed what people did.
Reflection: one thing you'd change
“I learned that communication is really important.”
“Next time I'd ask a few members to try the guide before it went out, because two steps confused people and I had to fix them halfway.”
Why it scoresThe first is true of everyone. The second is specific, honest, and fixes a weak spot you only found once the guide was in use.
The full answer
Moving leisure centre members onto a booking app
I work on reception at a leisure centre. We moved class bookings to an app with two weeks' notice, and many of our regulars had always booked by phone.
My manager asked me to make sure regular members knew how to book before phone bookings stopped, so nobody lost their place in a class.
I pulled the list of members who had booked by phone in the last month: 38 people. Rather than one email, I chose a way to reach each group. I wrote a one-page guide in plain words with screenshots, checked it with a colleague for errors, and handed it out at the desk. I phoned the members who never used email. On the calls, several said they would stop coming, so I asked what worried them. Most were unsure about card details or didn't have a smartphone. I took those reasons to my manager and suggested keeping one phone line open for 4 weeks and running two short help sessions at the desk. She agreed. I told each member the plan by the method they preferred, and said honestly that phone bookings would still end after the 4 weeks.
By the end of the 4 weeks, 31 of the 38 regulars were booking in the app. The other 7 book at the front desk, and my manager used the guide for the next system change.
Reflection: Next time I'd ask a few members to try the guide before it went out, because two steps confused people and I had to fix them halfway.
Tips that make the difference
- Pick a message that was hard
Bad news, a change people didn't want, or something technical for a non-expert. If everyone already agreed, there's nothing to influence.
- Name your audience
Say who you were talking to and what they needed. The AO line is about choosing the method for each person, so show you thought about it.
- Say how, not just what
Email, phone, face to face, a guide, a meeting. Say which you chose and why. It shows the AO line about choosing a method for each person.
- Show you listened
One line on a question you asked and what you learned from the answer. Listening is in both the AO and EO lines.
- Show someone changed their mind
Influencing is the result: a manager agreed, a customer accepted a decision, a team used the new form. Say who and what changed.
- Stay honest
If part of the news was bad, say you told people straight. The AO line asks you to stay honest and truthful when explaining opinions.
Use the same example for another question
Write your example as blocks first: one sentence each for the message, who heard it, how you reached each person, what you heard back, what you suggested and the result. For a different question, keep the blocks and change which ones go in the middle.
In one application, try to use a different example for each behaviour. Blocks help most at interview, when a follow-up comes and you already know which part of your story answers it.
Managing a Quality Service: tell me about a time you improved a service for customers.
Lead with what customers needed and where the service let them down, then what you changed, and how you checked it worked.
When bookings moved to an app, phone-only members were about to lose their classes. I found out what was stopping them, wrote a plain guide, and got my manager to keep a phone line for 4 weeks with help sessions at the desk. 31 of 38 moved over, and nobody lost their place.
What to do next
Before you write yours
7 to doTonight, think of one time you had to explain a change or deliver news someone didn't want: at work, at uni, or somewhere you volunteer. Write it as blocks, then build the answer above around it. To use one example for several questions, see the guide on whether one example can answer any question.
For the same layout on other behaviours, see the Working Together, Delivering at Pace and Managing a Quality Service guides.
Plum matches you to live Civil Service jobs, shows which behaviours each one tests, and helps you write and practise your examples. You apply on Civil Service Jobs itself.
Common questions
What is Communicating and Influencing in the Civil Service?
It is one of the nine Civil Service behaviours in Success Profiles. GOV.UK describes it as communicating purpose and direction with clarity, integrity and enthusiasm, and respecting the needs, responses and opinions of others.
What is a good example of Communicating and Influencing?
One message that was hard to land, where you chose how to reach each person, listened to their worries, and changed what someone did or agreed to. Explaining a change to customers, telling a team about a new process, or persuading a manager to try something all work well.
Does influencing mean I have to persuade a manager?
No. Influencing means people thought or did something differently because of how you communicated. Customers moving to a new system, a colleague using a new form, or a group agreeing a plan all count.
Can my Communicating and Influencing example come from outside work?
Yes. Success Profiles says examples can come from work experience, volunteering or a hobby. A society, a club, a group project or a community group all count, as long as you did the communicating.
How long should my answer be?
As long as the advert's word limit, often 250 words per behaviour. Keep the situation and task to two or three sentences, spend most of it on how you got the message across and what you heard back, and finish with the result and one line of reflection.
What score do I need to pass a behaviour?
Behaviours are usually scored out of 7, and the pass mark is set in the advert or candidate pack. 4 is common. Some adverts sift on a lead behaviour first, so check which one is named as lead.
Write your examples with Plum
See which behaviours each live job tests, and get help turning your experience into answers.