A strong Making Effective Decisions example, step by step
The panel scores how you decided, not just what you decided. A gut call that worked out scores lower than a careful one, so show what you checked, what you weighed and why you chose.
Below: the answer most people write next to the one that scores, the full answer, and how to reuse it for another question.
What the behaviour is asking for
Making Effective Decisions is one of the nine behaviours in Success Profiles, the framework that sets what each job tests. GOV.UK sums it up as: “Use evidence and knowledge to support accurate, expert decisions and advice. Carefully consider alternative options, implications and risks of decisions.”
At Administrative Officer (AO) level, one GOV.UK line is “identify and deal with any errors or gaps in information before making a decision”. Another is “consider the diverse needs of those affected by decisions and how it will impact them”.
At Executive Officer (EO) level, the lines include “take responsibility for making effective and fair decisions, in a timely manner” and “explain how decisions have been reached in a clear and concise way, both verbally and in writing”.
So the strongest answers show four things: evidence, options, the people affected, and a clear explanation. A gut call that happened to work out scores low, however good the result.
Your example doesn't have to come from an office job. Success Profiles says it might be at work or somewhere else, such as work experience, volunteering or a hobby. The example below is made up and comes from volunteering.
At work, the same shape fits choosing which cases in a backlog go first, or whether to grant a request the guidance doesn't quite cover.
Behaviours are usually scored out of 7. The advert or candidate pack sets the pass mark, and 4 is common. The lines below show what a high score looks like.
Each part: what most people write, and what scores
Your answer has five parts: Situation, Task, Action, Result and Reflection (STARR). For each one, here is the line most people write, the line that scores, and why. Spend most of your words on the action: around 150 words in a 250-word answer.
Situation: show there was a real choice
“I often have to make decisions in my role, and I'm good at making quick decisions under pressure.”
“I volunteer at a food bank. One Friday our delivery arrived with about half the usual stock, and we had two sessions to cover: Saturday morning and Monday evening.”
Why it scoresThe first describes you, not a moment. The second sets up a real choice: one delivery, two sessions, not enough for both.
Task: say what you had to decide
“I had to sort it out.”
“The session lead was away, so it was my call how to split the stock fairly between the two sessions.”
Why it scoresThe second says the decision was yours and names the test you set yourself: fair. That matches the EO line about effective and fair decisions.
Action: where the marks are
“I used my judgement and decided to give everything out on Saturday, because that's our busiest day.”
“I checked the last 4 weeks' sign-in sheets and found Monday's were incomplete, so I asked the Monday volunteers for their real numbers. I weighed three options against who each would leave out. I chose to split by expected households, and kept back 6 parcels for people who can't come in person.”
Why it scores“My judgement” can't be scored. The second shows evidence, a gap in the data fixed before deciding, options weighed, and the needs of the people affected: the GOV.UK lines, in plain words.
Result: what the decision led to
“It worked out fine and everyone was happy.”
“All 46 households across both sessions got a parcel, smaller than usual but no one was turned away, and the 6 held back went out to people who couldn't come in.”
Why it scoresThe first can't be checked. The second shows the decision did what you said it would, with a number, and that someone else trusted it enough to reuse it.
Reflection: one thing you'd change
“I learned that I'm a natural decision maker.”
“Next time I'd check the sign-in sheets were complete every week, so the numbers are ready when a quick decision is needed.”
Why it scoresThe first is a claim about yourself. The second is specific, honest, and fixes the weak spot the story itself showed.
The full answer
Splitting a short delivery at a food bank
I volunteer at a community food bank. One Friday our delivery arrived with about half the usual stock, and we had two sessions to cover: Saturday and Monday evening.
The session lead was away, so it was my call how to split the stock fairly so neither session ran out.
I checked the last 4 weeks' sign-in sheets. Saturday's were complete and averaged about 26 households, but two of Monday's were half blank, so I texted the Monday volunteers for their real numbers. That put Monday at about 20, not the 12 the sheets showed. I wrote down three options: give everything out on Saturday, split it 50/50, or split by expected households with smaller parcels. The first would have left Monday's visitors with nothing, and many of them work days. A 50/50 split would have run Saturday short. I chose the split that evening, so volunteers could pack the night before, and kept back 6 parcels for people who can't come in person. I messaged the lead my numbers and reasons, and put a note on the door explaining the smaller parcels.
All 46 households across both sessions got a parcel, smaller than usual but no one was turned away, and the 6 held back went out to people who couldn't come in. The lead kept the same split for the next short delivery.
Reflection: Next time I'd check the sign-in sheets were complete every week, so the numbers are ready when a quick decision is needed.
Tips that make the difference
- Pick a decision with options
If there was only one sensible choice, there is nothing to score. Name at least two options and why you ruled one out.
- Show the evidence
Say what you checked before you chose: figures, guidance, records, what people told you. That's the first half of the GOV.UK summary: use evidence and knowledge.
- Fix a gap first
If something was missing or wrong in the information, say how you dealt with it before deciding. It's one of the AO lines.
- Name who it affects
One line on the people your decision would hit, and how you allowed for them, covers the lines about diverse needs.
- Explain your reasons
Say who you told, how, and what you said. The EO line asks you to explain how you reached a decision, verbally and in writing.
- Ask for advice, then decide
Checking with someone is fine, and it's in the AO and EO lines. Just make sure the final call in your story is yours.
Use the same example for another question
Write your example as blocks first: one sentence each for the problem, what you checked, the options, what you chose, how you explained it and the result. For a different question, keep the blocks and change which ones go in the middle.
In one application, try to use a different example for each behaviour. Blocks help most at interview, when a follow-up comes and you already know which part of your story answers it.
Communicating and Influencing: tell me about a time you explained something difficult to people.
Lead with what people needed to hear and why it was hard, then how you said it, in what form, and how they took it.
Our delivery came in at half the usual stock, so every parcel had to be smaller. I sent the lead a short message with the numbers and my reasons, and put a plain note on the door so visitors knew why before they reached the table. No one complained at the table, and two regulars offered to explain the smaller parcels to people they knew who come on Mondays.
What to do next
Before you write yours
7 to doTonight, think of one choice you had to make where the answer wasn't obvious: at work, at uni, or somewhere you volunteer. Write it as blocks, then build the answer above around it. To use one example for several questions, see the guide on whether one example can answer any question.
For the same layout on other behaviours, see the Working Together, Delivering at Pace and Managing a Quality Service guides.
Plum matches you to live Civil Service jobs, shows which behaviours each one tests, and helps you write and practise your examples. You apply on Civil Service Jobs itself.
Common questions
What is Making Effective Decisions in the Civil Service?
It is one of the nine Civil Service behaviours in Success Profiles. GOV.UK describes it as using evidence and knowledge to support accurate decisions and advice, and carefully considering other options, implications and risks.
What is a good example of Making Effective Decisions?
One real choice with at least two options, where you checked the facts, dealt with any gaps, weighed the options and the people affected, chose, and explained why. Splitting limited resources, handling a request that didn't fit the rules, or choosing between suppliers all work well.
Can my example be a decision that went wrong?
It can, if your process was sound and you say what you learned. But a decision that worked, made for clear reasons, is easier to score. Avoid examples where luck did the work.
Can my Making Effective Decisions example come from outside work?
Yes. Success Profiles says examples can come from work experience, volunteering or a hobby. A society, a club, a group project or caring for someone all count, as long as the decision was yours.
How long should my answer be?
As long as the advert's word limit, often 250 words per behaviour. Keep the situation and task to two or three sentences, spend most of it on what you checked, weighed and chose, and finish with the result and one line of reflection.
What score do I need to pass a behaviour?
Behaviours are usually scored out of 7, and the pass mark is set in the advert or candidate pack. 4 is common. Some adverts sift on a lead behaviour first, so check which one is named as lead.
Write your examples with Plum
See which behaviours each live job tests, and get help turning your experience into answers.