What is a Civil Service sift?
3 possible outcomes · Cefas EO, ref 489092In the Civil Service, the sift is the first stage after you press submit. A small panel, often including the hiring manager, reads every application and scores it. Nobody interviews you until your written application has passed the sift.
You can't talk your way through it. The panel only has what you wrote: your CV, your personal statement and any behaviour answers the form asked for. Anything not on the page doesn't get marks.
This page explains what gets scored, how the scores work, what the panel can and can't give marks for, and what each result on Civil Service Jobs means. It uses a real advert that is open now, so you can see the sift written out in full.
What the sift panel actually scores
Civil Service jobs use a framework called Success Profiles. Each advert picks what it will test, such as behaviours (things like Working Together, shown with a real example from your past), experience, strengths and technical skills.
At the sift, the panel usually scores only what you can show on paper: your experience (from your CV and personal statement) and one or more behaviours (from the short answers the form asks for). Strengths, if the advert tests them, usually come later, at interview.
The advert's "Selection process details" section says exactly what is scored at application stage. Read it before you write a word. It is the panel's marking guide, printed for you.
Many adverts name a lead behaviour. If lots of people apply, the panel may first sift on that one answer alone, and only read the rest for people who pass it. That makes the lead behaviour answer the most important thing you write.
A real sift, written out: the Cefas Aquarist job
This Executive Officer job at Cefas (the Centre for Environment, Fisheries and Aquaculture Science) in Weymouth spells its sift out clearly, which makes it a good one to learn from.
You send a CV, a personal statement of up to 500 words on how you meet the essential criteria, and a 250-word answer on the lead behaviour, Managing a Quality Service.
The advert says you get a score from 1 to 7 on three things: the lead behaviour, your CV and experience, and your personal statement. Three separate scores, so a strong CV can't make up for a missing behaviour answer.
It also says that if a large number of people apply, there may be an initial sift on the lead behaviour alone. Pass that and you may go on to the full sift, or straight to interview.
Aquarist
- Pay
- £30,860
- Where
- Weymouth · onsite
- Closes
- Fri 27 Nov, 23:55
- Ref
- 489092
The behaviour question is printed in the advert: a time you found the quality of your work wasn't meeting the required service standard, what you did and what happened. When the question is printed, answer that question, not the behaviour in general.
How the scores work
Behaviours and experience are usually scored out of 7. The advert or candidate pack sets the pass mark. A pass isn't always enough: if more people pass than there are interview slots, the highest scores go through.
Each score is for what you personally did. The panel can't give marks for what "we" or "the team" did, for a job title, or for a word like "hardworking". It needs evidence it can point to.
Civil Service staff who sift applications say the same in public threads: a line like "I was responsible for managing stakeholders" could be true of someone who is bad at their job, so it can't earn a score. Write what you did and what changed.
Lines the sift can't score, and what to write instead
A duty, not an action
“I was responsible for managing stakeholders.”
“I ran a weekly 15-minute call with the 3 site leads, so delays were raised on Monday instead of Friday.”
Why it scoresThe first is a job description. The second says what you did, who with, and what it changed, so the panel can score it.
An adjective, not evidence
“I am hardworking and conscientious.”
“When 2 colleagues were off, I covered their returns as well as mine and cleared the backlog in a week.”
Why it scoresAnyone can say they are hardworking. A moment that shows it is the only thing the panel can mark.
“We”, not “I”
“We improved how the team handled complaints.”
“I rewrote our complaint reply template and checked it with the team lead. Repeat complaints fell over the next month.”
Why it scoresThe panel scores you, not your team. Say what the team did in a few words, then spend your words on your part.
The advert's words copied back
“I deliver a quality service and always meet the required standard.”
“I noticed 1 in 5 of my case notes was missing a date, so I added a check to my end-of-day list.”
Why it scoresRepeating the behaviour's own words shows you read the advert, not that you have done it. Staff who sift say it is one of the clearest signs of an AI-written answer.
What happens after the sift
When the panel has scored everyone, the recruiter issues one of three results on Civil Service Jobs. GOV.UK's guidance for recruiters names them:
Progress: you are emailed and move to "Selected for Interview 1". Unsuccessful: you are emailed and move to "Rejected after Sift". Hold: you are not emailed, and move to "On hold after sift".
Hold can mean you passed but there wasn't room at interview this time. Over a third of live adverts on Plum mention a reserve list, so it isn't always the end.
The same guidance says any behaviour or technical scores the panel enters at the sift can be seen by the candidate. Check your application centre for them. They tell you which part to fix before you apply again.
What to do next
Before you submit
6 to doIf you are waiting to hear back, the guide on hearing nothing after you apply explains each Civil Service Jobs status and how long it tends to take.
To see which live adverts name a lead behaviour, use the lead list guide. To write the behaviour answer itself, the STAR workbook takes you through it step by step.
Plum shows which behaviours each live job tests and helps you turn your experience into answers the sift can score.
Common questions
What does sift mean in a Civil Service application?
The sift is the stage where a panel reads and scores your written application (usually your CV, personal statement and behaviour answers) against what the advert asked for. Only applications that score well enough are invited to interview.
Who sifts Civil Service applications?
Usually a small panel that includes people from the hiring team. They score each application against the criteria in the advert, then the recruiter issues the results on Civil Service Jobs.
What is a lead behaviour in a sift?
It is the behaviour the advert says matters most. If many people apply, the panel may sift on the lead behaviour answer alone first, and only score the rest for people who pass it.
What score do you need to pass a Civil Service sift?
Behaviours and experience are usually scored out of 7, and the advert or candidate pack sets the pass mark. If more people pass than there are interview places, the highest scores go through.
What does 'On hold after sift' mean?
The panel has not rejected you, but you have not been invited to interview yet. You are not emailed when this happens. It can mean you passed but places were limited, and some campaigns keep a reserve list.
Can I see my sift scores?
GOV.UK's guidance for recruiters says behaviour and technical scores entered at the sift can be seen by the candidate once results are issued. Look in your application centre on Civil Service Jobs.
Write answers the sift can score
See what each live job tests at the sift, and get help turning your experience into answers.